eIDAS & Trust Services
What Is PAdES? The AdES Signature Formats Explained
PAdES (PDF Advanced Electronic Signatures) is the ETSI standard for digital signatures embedded in PDF documents, specified in ETSI EN 319 142. It is one member of the AdES family, a set of signature formats that share the same model and the same four baseline levels but differ in the container: XAdES for XML, CAdES for binary CMS, JAdES for JSON and ASiC for packaging signed files together.
The family
CAdES (ETSI EN 319 122) builds on CMS, the Cryptographic Message Syntax behind PKCS #7, and can sign any binary content. XAdES (ETSI EN 319 132) builds on XML Signature and dominates in e-invoicing and government data exchange. PAdES (ETSI EN 319 142) places a CAdES-style signature inside the PDF, so the document and its signature travel as one file that an ordinary PDF reader can verify. JAdES (ETSI TS 119 182) builds on JSON Web Signature for APIs. ASiC (ETSI EN 319 162), Associated Signature Containers, is a ZIP container that holds one or more files with detached XAdES or CAdES signatures.
The format says how a signature is encoded. It says nothing about its legal level. A PAdES signature can be advanced or qualified depending on the certificate and the device that created it.
The four baseline levels
Every AdES format defines the same four baseline levels, each adding to the one before.
B-B is the basic signature: the signed data, the signing certificate and signed attributes such as the claimed signing time. That time comes from the signer's own clock and proves nothing by itself.
B-T adds a time stamp from a time stamping authority over the signature. It proves that the signature existed at that time, which is what later allows a validator to say that the certificate was valid when the signature was made.
B-LT adds the validation material: the certificate chain and the revocation data (CRLs or OCSP responses) needed to validate the signature. The signature can then be validated without contacting the certificate authority, which may no longer be serving that information.
B-LTA adds an archive time stamp over the signature and all the validation material, and allows further archive time stamps later. Each new one protects the whole structure before the algorithms or the previous time stamp certificate become unreliable.
How PAdES does it in a PDF
A PAdES signature is a DER-encoded CMS SignedData object stored in the Contents entry of a PDF signature dictionary. It covers the file except for the space reserved for the signature itself. The validation material for B-LT goes into a Document Security Store (DSS) dictionary added to the PDF in an incremental update, and the archive time stamp for B-LTA is a document time stamp, a separate signature field containing only an RFC 3161 token over the document.
Because each step is an incremental update appended to the file, a PDF can be signed by several people in turn and extended to a higher level later without invalidating the earlier signatures.
Which level to ask for
For a document that is checked once and forgotten, B-B or B-T may be enough. For anything that must be verifiable after the signer's certificate has expired, which comes quickly with the short-lived certificates that remote signing services issue, ask for B-LT at least. For documents kept for years, B-LTA with a plan for renewing the archive time stamp is the level that was designed for the job.
Try it yourself — free tools
- Timestamp Checker — decode the RFC 3161 time stamp tokens used at levels B-T and B-LTA
- Certificate Checker — check whether the signing certificate inside a signature is qualified
How MI Support IT can help
PKI Tools is built by MI Support IT, a Danish IT company with deep specialization in enterprise PKI: ADCS design and health checks, Venafi certificate automation, key ceremonies and CP/CPS documentation. Read about our PKI services or get in touch.
PKI Glossary
- Long-Term Validation (LTV)The techniques that keep a digital signature verifiable after its certificate has expired, been revoked or its algorithms have aged.
- Qualified Electronic Time StampA time stamp from a qualified trust service provider that carries a legal presumption of the accuracy of its time and the integrity of the data.
- Qualified Electronic Signature (QES)The highest eIDAS signature level: an advanced signature made with a qualified device and a qualified certificate, legally equal to a handwritten signature.
- PKCS#7 / P7BThe certificate-bundle format CAs use to deliver a certificate together with its chain — never with a private key.
- Certificate Revocation List (CRL)The CA-signed list of revoked certificates — and the single file whose expiry can take down an entire PKI.
- Online Certificate Status Protocol (OCSP)Real-time revocation checking for a single certificate — plus stapling, and why must-staple never took off.
- Browse all terms →