eIDAS & Trust Services

What Is Long-Term Validation (LTV)?

Long-Term Validation (LTV) is the set of techniques that keep a digital signature verifiable long after it was created: embedding the certificates and revocation data needed to validate it, and protecting everything with time stamps that are renewed over time. It exists because signed documents routinely have to outlive the certificates that signed them.

Why signatures outlive certificates

A contract may need to stand for ten or thirty years. A signing certificate is typically valid for one to three years, and certificates issued by remote signing services are often far shorter-lived than that. The mathematics of the signature still verifies after the certificate expires, but the question a validator has to answer is different: was the certificate valid, and not revoked, at the moment of signing?

Answering that years later runs into three problems. The time of signing has to be proven, because the time in the signature is the signer's own claim. The revocation information has to be available, and certificate authorities do not serve CRLs and OCSP responses for expired certificates forever, or may have ceased to exist. And the algorithms age: a hash function or key size that is sound today may be breakable in the future, at which point an old signature could be forged.

The three ingredients

A signature time stamp from a time stamping authority fixes the signature in time. Anything that happens to the certificate afterwards, whether expiry or revocation, no longer affects the signature.

Embedded validation data, meaning the full certificate chain plus the CRLs or OCSP responses that show the certificates were good at the time, makes the signature self-contained. In PDF this material lives in the Document Security Store.

Archive time stamps cover the signature, the earlier time stamps and all validation data. Before the algorithm or the certificate behind the latest time stamp becomes weak or expires, a new archive time stamp with current algorithms is added on top. The chain of time stamps carries the proof forward indefinitely.

In the ETSI baseline levels these correspond to B-T, B-LT and B-LTA. An "LTV-enabled" PDF, in the wording of common PDF readers, is one where the reader found all the validation data it needs inside the file.

Collect the evidence early

The validation data has to be collected while it is still available, ideally at or shortly after signing. If a document was signed at the basic level and the certificate authority has since stopped publishing revocation data for that certificate, the evidence cannot be recreated. Upgrading signatures on receipt, before archiving, is the safe habit.

Validation itself follows ETSI EN 319 102-1, which defines the procedure and the three possible results: TOTAL-PASSED, TOTAL-FAILED and INDETERMINATE. An old signature without time stamps or validation data often ends up as INDETERMINATE: not proven invalid, but not provable either.

Preservation services

Renewing archive time stamps for decades is an operational task, and eIDAS defines a trust service for it. A qualified preservation service for qualified electronic signatures (Article 34, and Article 40 for seals) may only be provided by a qualified trust service provider and must use procedures and technologies capable of extending the trustworthiness of the signature beyond its technological validity period. ETSI TS 119 511 sets the policy and security requirements for such providers.

This is distinct from the qualified electronic archiving service that eIDAS 2 introduced, which concerns the preservation of electronic documents as such.

Try it yourself — free tools

  • Timestamp Checker — decode signature and archive time stamp tokens and check the authority against the EU Trusted List
  • Certificate Checker — inspect the signing certificate, its validity period and its revocation pointers

How MI Support IT can help

PKI Tools is built by MI Support IT, a Danish IT company with deep specialization in enterprise PKI: ADCS design and health checks, Venafi certificate automation, key ceremonies and CP/CPS documentation. Read about our PKI services or get in touch.

PKI Glossary